Journal
13 min read

Rental car scratch: when does it count as damage?

Diesen Artikel auf Deutsch lesen

No Swiss law sets a size, so every rental company draws its own line. Most published rules sit between 2 and 3 centimetres: Europcar Germany charges scratches from 2 cm, Mobility wants anything larger than a CHF 2 coin reported, and at DRAIV anything under 2 cm is wear.

The numbers on this page come from the rules the companies publish themselves, the Swiss Code of Obligations and Swissmint. We read all of them on 2 November 2026, and the sources are listed below. If your rental contract says something different, the contract applies.

The short answer

QuestionAnswer
Is there a legal size limit?No. The law only says you return the car in the condition that results from normal, agreed use (Art. 267 CO).
Where do companies draw the line?For scratches mostly between 20 and 30 mm, for dents between 15 and 50 mm
And at DRAIV?Under 2 cm is wear, from 2 cm it is damage, the same for scratches and dents
What do you pay for damage?At DRAIV the repair based on a quote, at most your deductible
How do you measure without a ruler?10-centime coin 19.15 mm, 20-centime coin 21.05 mm, CHF 2 coin 27.4 mm
What helps most in a dispute?Photos at pickup and at return, with a coin next to every mark

A hand runs a fingernail across a short scratch on the white rear door of a car in a parking garage

Swiss law has no centimetres

Legally a rental car is a rented item, and the tenancy rules of the Code of Obligations apply. Art. 267 CO says you must return it in the condition that results from use in line with the contract. Normal wear is paid for by the rental price. Under paragraph 2, any agreement that commits you in advance to pay more than the actual damage is void.

Where normal wear ends, the law does not say. Each company sets that in its own terms, and some don't set it at all.

After the return, Art. 267a CO matters. The company must check the condition at return and report defects you are liable for straight away. If it doesn't, it loses its claim, except for defects that a normal inspection could not have found.

How companies draw the line

Drag the slider to the length of your scratch or the size of your dent. The list underneath shows who still lets it pass as wear.

For rentals and car sharing, meaning rules for a single trip or rental:

CompanyScratchDentWhat the rule is
DRAIV, Switzerlandfree under 2 cmfree under 2 cmrental rule, see below
Europcar, Germanyscratches under 2 cm freedents under 5 cm freerental rule, with a price list from 2 cm
Hertz, New Zealandfree if the paint is intact, up to 20 mm if it is brokenfree up to 20 mm, paint intactrental rule
Avis, Australiafree under 25 mm, polishablefree under 25 mm, paint intactrental rule
Mobility, Switzerlandreport anything larger than a CHF 2 coin (27.4 mm)samereporting threshold for the driver, not a price rule
Getaround, Europedamage only from 5.5 cmsamecompensation for the car owner, only if the damage is clearly tied to one rental
Europcar, United Kingdom (2017)free up to 75 mmfree up to 25 mmrental rule
Turo, United Statesprior damage only from 3 inches (7.6 cm)samerule for damage that existed before the trip

We found no published limit at Sixt, Hertz Switzerland, Avis and Budget Switzerland or GoMore Switzerland. Europcar Switzerland says small damage is charged from a price list kept at its branches and not published online.

For lease returns, meaning after years of use:

RuleScratchDentStone chip and wheel
Porsche Financial Services Switzerland, based on the SLV and AGVS guidelinefree under 30 mm if the base coat is intactunder 20 mm and under 1 mm deep, at most 2 per panel and 6 per carstone chips under 2 mm, wheels up to 20 mm
Carvolution, Switzerland (car subscription)longer than 100 mm not acceptedat most 2 dents up to 25 mmno millimetre figure
VMF, Germanyon door edges and bumpers free under 20 mmup to 3 dents of up to 20 mm per panelalloy wheels up to 20 mm without material loss
BVRLA, United Kingdomfree up to 25 mm, polishable, at most 4 per panelup to 15 mmwheels up to 50 mm around the whole rim

Two things stand out. Lease rules cover a car driven for three or four years and still land close to the rental rules. And the coin comparisons are often off: Carvolution calls 25 mm "the size of a two-franc coin", which Swissmint measures at 27.4 mm. Europcar UK equates 25 mm with a 10p coin, which is 24.5 mm.

What a scratch over the line costs

In our comparison only Europcar Germany publishes what damage costs, in a price list valid from 23 September 2025. Its first band starts exactly at 2 cm. A 2 to 5 cm scratch on the front bumper is listed at 473.35 to 607.83 depending on car class, a 2 to 5 cm scuff on an alloy wheel at 155.26 to 198.59. The list names no currency and applies to the German market.

From Switzerland we know single cases from consumer programmes. SRF's "Kassensturz" reported in 2016 on the equivalent of 500 francs charged for a small scratch and, in a second case, 1,500 francs. The magazine "Beobachter" described a claim of 204 francs in 2019 for underbody damage found a week after return. The rental company dropped it as a goodwill gesture.

How to measure without a ruler

You almost always have coins on you, and Swissmint publishes their diameters to a hundredth of a millimetre.

CoinDiameter
10 centimes19.15 mm
20 centimes21.05 mm
1 franc23.20 mm
2 francs27.40 mm
5 francs31.45 mm

For the 2 cm limit that means: if the mark disappears completely under a 10-centime coin, it is shorter. If it sticks out past a 20-centime coin, it is longer. Careful with the half-franc, at 18.20 mm it is smaller than the 10-centime coin.

The second check is your fingernail, which Mobility describes on its help pages. Run your nail across the scratch, not along it. If it glides over, usually only the clear coat is scratched, or something sits on top of the paint, like paint from a wall or rub-off from a guard rail. In our own fleet we polish those spots ourselves. If your nail catches, the clear coat is through, and the car needs a smart repair shop or paint.

Stone chip in the windscreen

Swiss law sets no size for glass either. Art. 71a of the ordinance on technical requirements for road vehicles requires a clear, undistorted view. Carglass Switzerland repairs a chip if it is smaller than a CHF 2 coin and more than 6 cm from the edge, otherwise it replaces the windscreen.

At DRAIV you pay nothing for a chip under 2 cm without a crack. Tell us anyway, so we can have it repaired before it cracks. A crack in the glass is always damage.

How DRAIV handles scratches and dents

Until now we decided case by case. From now on we have a rule you know before you rent:

  • We measure the longest point. For a scratch the length, for a dent, chip or wheel scuff the diameter.
  • Under 2 cm is wear. We note it in the car's profile so nobody pins it on you later, and you pay nothing.
  • From 2 cm it is damage. We get a quote from a garage. We only give you a figure once that quote is in, and we never do the maths ourselves. You pay the repair, at most your deductible.
  • Some things are always damage, however small: a crack in the glass, a tear or hole in plastic or upholstery, loose or sticking-out parts.
  • Several marks from one cause count together. A scrape band of many short lines from a wall is measured as one.

Before we attribute any damage to you, we open the photos of the rental before yours. If the mark is already visible there, it has nothing to do with you.

Close-up of a silver alloy wheel with a scuff on the rim edge, a hand at the bottom right points a phone at the wheel

At pickup you take four photos in the app, one per side, and can add up to six more. Use those six for every mark you notice, with a coin next to it. At return you take four photos again. Under our GTC (§ 4.2) we presume that anything not in your pickup photos or in the car's profile happened during your rental. You can show otherwise, for example with the return photos of the previous rental, which we share on request.

Every damage we know of is recorded in the car's profile, with a photo and a date. Still, send us everything you notice, including scratches under 2 cm and spots you're not sure about. An extra photo costs you nothing: if the mark is already recorded, nothing changes. If it's new, it goes into the profile with your photo, and nobody can pin it on you later. The easiest way is the six extra photos in the app at pickup, otherwise by WhatsApp or to [email protected].

You choose your deductible when you book. It is the most you will ever be left with if something happens: CHF 2,000 with Comfort, CHF 200 with Premium. If you prove your own cover, you can also choose Basis with CHF 5,000 or Essence with CHF 10,000. The glossary entry on the deductible explains how it works.

What you can do on every rental, with any company

  • Before you drive off, photograph all four sides, plus the wheels, the bumper corners and the windscreen. They sit low or in the light, and they're easy to miss on a first walk around.
  • Put a coin next to the mark in every close-up. Then the size shows without a ruler.
  • Don't sign a report you haven't read. SRF's consumer programme "Espresso" gives the same advice: once you acknowledge damage with your signature, you can hardly dispute it.
  • If you return at night or without staff, photograph the car from all sides again, with flash in a parking garage.
  • Ask before you rent from what size your company charges a scratch. An answer in centimetres is a good answer.

Frequently asked questions

When does a scratch on a rental car count as damage?

No law sets a size, so each company draws its own line. Europcar Germany charges scratches from 2 cm and dents from 5 cm, Mobility in Switzerland wants anything larger than a CHF 2 coin reported, and Getaround counts damage from 5.5 cm. At DRAIV a scratch or dent under 2 cm is wear, from 2 cm it is damage.

How do I measure a scratch without a ruler?

With coins. A Swiss 10-centime coin is 19.15 mm across, a 20-centime coin 21.05 mm, a CHF 2 coin 27.4 mm. If the mark disappears completely under a 10-centime coin, it is shorter than 2 cm. Put the coin right next to the mark when you take the photo.

Do I need to report small scratches at pickup?

Photograph every one, even the smallest. Many rental companies attribute anything not documented at pickup to your rental, and at DRAIV that is in our GTC under § 4.2. With us you take four photos at pickup, one per side, and can add up to six more.

What do I pay at DRAIV for a scratch over 2 cm?

The repair, based on a garage's quote, at most your deductible. You choose it when you book: CHF 2,000 with Comfort, CHF 200 with Premium. If you prove your own cover, you can also choose Basis with CHF 5,000 or Essence with CHF 10,000.

Does a dent count differently from a scratch?

With many companies, yes. Europcar Germany lets dents pass up to just under 5 cm but scratches only under 2 cm. Lease-return rules such as those of Porsche Financial Services Switzerland also require a dent to be less than 1 mm deep. At DRAIV the same 2 cm limit applies to scratches and dents.

What about a stone chip in the windscreen?

Swiss law sets no size, it requires a clear, undistorted view (Art. 71a of the vehicle technical requirements ordinance, VTS). Carglass Switzerland repairs a chip if it is smaller than a CHF 2 coin and more than 6 cm from the edge. At DRAIV you pay nothing for a chip under 2 cm without a crack, a crack in the glass is always damage.

Can a rental company charge me for a scratch weeks after I returned the car?

Only within limits. Under Art. 267a of the Swiss Code of Obligations the company must inspect the car at return and report defects immediately. If it does not, it loses the claim, except for defects a normal inspection could not have found.

Sources

  • Mobility, help and FAQ, section on reporting damage: mobility.ch
  • Europcar Germany, damage management (2023) and price list "Direkte Schadenregulierung", valid from 23.09.2025: europcar.de
  • Europcar Switzerland, claims management: europcar.ch
  • Europcar UK, "Smooth Journey", August 2017 (PDF on europcar.co.uk)
  • Hertz New Zealand, "Fair Wear and Tear" (PDF on images.hertz.com)
  • Avis Australia, "Fair Wear and Tear Guidelines", revision 27.03.2024 (PDF on avis.com.au)
  • Getaround, "Understanding when to report damage", updated 14.11.2024: getaround.com
  • Turo, "Claims with prior damage": help.turo.com
  • Porsche Financial Services Switzerland, vehicle return: porsche.com
  • Carvolution, return standards (PDF on carvolution.com)
  • VMF, "Die Faire Fahrzeugbewertung", 06/2022, published by Deutsche Leasing (PDF)
  • BVRLA, Fair Wear and Tear, figures quoted in UK Financial Ombudsman Service decision DRN-3465992: financial-ombudsman.org.uk
  • Swiss Code of Obligations, Art. 267 and 267a, version of 1 October 2026: fedlex.admin.ch
  • VTS, Art. 71a: fedlex.admin.ch
  • Carglass Switzerland, FAQ: carglass.ch
  • Swissmint, technical data of Swiss coins in circulation (PDF on swissmint.ch)
  • SRF "Kassensturz", 30.06.2016, and SRF "Espresso", 16.07.2020: srf.ch
  • "Beobachter", 05.08.2019: beobachter.ch
  • DRAIV, GTC, § 4.2 and § 5.2: draiv.ch/en/terms-of-service

If a figure here and one in our GTC differ, the GTC apply. How a pickup with photos works with us is in the glossary under damage inspection. And if you're running late, here is what that costs.

Rent a car with no desk and usually no deposit

Book on the web or in the app, unlock with your phone and drive off.